Rain Gutters or French Drains?
-
- Member
- Posts: 6446
- Joined: Mon. Apr. 16, 2007 9:34 pm
- Location: Central Maine
- Hand Fed Coal Stove: DS Machine 1300 with hopper
- Coal Size/Type: Blaschak Anthracite Nut
- Other Heating: Oil hot water radiators (fuel oil); propane
I have never dared to put rain gutters on my house for fear of excessive snow melt causing them to fill with ice. But I’m finally getting my house properly insulated. My cellar is quite damp even when it doesn't rain, and sometimes when it rains hard I get a couple inches of water in the low spots. The foundation is large field stones, with granite slabs above grade. There is one roof valley in particular that dumps a lot of water into a corner where it is hard to slope the soil away from the house. If you go down cellar near that corner, you can see the water just flowing in around the rocks.
There seem to be two schools of thought on getting the water away from the house:
(1) Standard rain gutters, which should be OK after insulation is done.
(2) French drains along the drip line of the roof.
Yes, I know, I could have done the French drains years ago, I just didn’t know it was an option. I tend to think the French drains would be less maintenance and trouble than gutters in the long run. But I’m puzzled by those inexpensive black corrugated/perforated drain pipes – it seems like the water should just exit through the bottom perforations and sink into the ground like it does now. Advice / opinions / experience, anyone?
There seem to be two schools of thought on getting the water away from the house:
(1) Standard rain gutters, which should be OK after insulation is done.
(2) French drains along the drip line of the roof.
Yes, I know, I could have done the French drains years ago, I just didn’t know it was an option. I tend to think the French drains would be less maintenance and trouble than gutters in the long run. But I’m puzzled by those inexpensive black corrugated/perforated drain pipes – it seems like the water should just exit through the bottom perforations and sink into the ground like it does now. Advice / opinions / experience, anyone?
Are we talking about the same thing here? French Drains require excavation, lining the trench with gravel and installing one of those perforated pipes to drain the water. Not sure what you mean by French Drain installed along the drip line of the roof... As explained to me by an engineer, French Drains are used to direct water away from a foundation; i.e. water that is flows towards your house down a grade.
if the water near your foundation comes from the roof runoff, it would be far cheaper to install gutters on the roof line.
if the water near your foundation comes from the roof runoff, it would be far cheaper to install gutters on the roof line.
-
- Member
- Posts: 4197
- Joined: Wed. Oct. 03, 2012 9:53 am
- Location: Western Massachusetts
- Baseburners & Antiques: Crawford 40, PP Stewart No. 14, Abendroth Bros "Record 40"
- Coal Size/Type: Stove / Anthracite.
- Other Heating: Oil fired, forced hot air.
If you go with gutters, have commercial sized downspouts installed. They are less likely to get clogged and will flow lots of water.
- WNY
- Member
- Posts: 6307
- Joined: Mon. Nov. 14, 2005 8:40 am
- Location: Cuba, NY
- Hot Air Coal Stoker Stove: Keystoker 90K, Leisure Line Hyfire I
- Coal Size/Type: Rice
- Contact:
I had gutters put on with the new roof 8+ years ago and never had a problem with them ripping off. we've had some ice build up at times, but usually not too bad.
If you have good attic insulation, the stuff doesn't melt as much and you don't get the ice build up.
You can also roof rake , long pole with a a puller on the end to pull the snow off the ends of your eves if you get a lot of snow, thats what I do (and need to today or tomorrow, we just got 10+ inches and it helps keep the ice from forming at the ends.
If you have good attic insulation, the stuff doesn't melt as much and you don't get the ice build up.
You can also roof rake , long pole with a a puller on the end to pull the snow off the ends of your eves if you get a lot of snow, thats what I do (and need to today or tomorrow, we just got 10+ inches and it helps keep the ice from forming at the ends.
- Keepaeyeonit
- Member
- Posts: 1681
- Joined: Wed. Mar. 24, 2010 7:18 pm
- Location: Northeast Ohio.( Grand river wine country )
- Baseburners & Antiques: Glenwood #8
- Coal Size/Type: Nut & stove
- Other Heating: 49 year old oil furnace, and finally a new heat pump
I have gutters on my house but the french drain thing seems good too but I would think It will add a tremendous amount of water to your footer drains due to the fact It would be so close to the house unless your overhangs were long.The water will like anything find the easiest way to flow so It will drain through the pipe providing Its put in right( the trench needs to have a pitch to It) and back filled with the right stone(I use 57 for back filling drain pipe).you will get some water seeping into the ground but not enough to worry about and most people don't realize that even sdr drain pipe with holes only down one side needs to be installed with the holes down facing the bottom of the trench. If you go with the French drain you may want to get with the sock to help keep the pipe cleaner longer. Keepaeyeonit
-
- Member
- Posts: 6446
- Joined: Mon. Apr. 16, 2007 9:34 pm
- Location: Central Maine
- Hand Fed Coal Stove: DS Machine 1300 with hopper
- Coal Size/Type: Blaschak Anthracite Nut
- Other Heating: Oil hot water radiators (fuel oil); propane
Yes, bad choice of words – drain would be installed in the ground, where the drip line is. I haven’t priced either method. But I would need gutters in a couple places anyway, like above the doors and where the garage roof drips and kills my wife’s flowers. Just hate to start hanging more stuff off my house…NJJoe wrote:Not sure what you mean by French Drain installed along the drip line of the roof... it would be far cheaper to install gutters on the roof line
Ha! You guys with new houses may have footer drains. I have big rocks for a foundation weighing probably one to three tons each, with granite slabs set on edge above grade. Footer drains are for wimps.Keepaeyeonit wrote:the french drain thing seems good too but I would think It will add a tremendous amount of water to your footer drains
Keepaeyeonit wrote:If you go with the French drain you may want to get with the sock to help keep the pipe cleaner longer.
Yes, I have read about those. Apparently more expensive to buy but less expensive to install. I have also read that it is better to use smooth PVC pipe rather than the cheap flexible corrugated stuff, so you can run a snake through to clean it out.
- coalkirk
- Member
- Posts: 5185
- Joined: Wed. May. 17, 2006 8:12 pm
- Location: Forest Hill MD
- Stoker Coal Boiler: 1981 EFM DF520 retired
- Hand Fed Coal Stove: Jotul 507 on standby
- Coal Size/Type: Lehigh anthracite/rice coal
Definitely gutters. Even with drip line drains under the roofline your basement will still be wet.
-
- Member
- Posts: 286
- Joined: Wed. Jan. 29, 2014 1:42 pm
- Location: N/W Pa. Meadville, Pa.
- Hand Fed Coal Stove: Sears circulator air tight stove.
- Other Heating: Crown 115,000 BTU oil fired boiler(house) Weil Mclain 150,000BTU oil fired boiler(Shop)
rberq, two questions.
1.) Do you have enough fall to properly pitch your drain tile to daylight? Proper pitch being between 1/8" - 1/4" per foot of run. Anymore than 1/4" per foot, the water can run away from the solids in it, and any less than 1/8" per foot the water is not following fast enough to carry the solids along. Either of these scenarios can lead to clogging of the tile.
2.) are your cellar walls cut stone, stacked field stone or rubble type construction. Digging in the area of rubble type can be a problem but can be done. Cut stone and stacked field stone are the easiest of the old foundations to work around, as they are more stable than the rubble type is.
Now, onto the main subject. If you wish dry up your cellar than digging out the foundation and installing a footer drain around the perimeter, with a membrane on the outside of the walls is your only real recourse to a wet basement. Adding gutters to the prevent the water from getting the chance to soak into the ground will help a lot, but if the water is coming from another source, the gutters will not cure the problem.
Either way you do this, you will need to dig some ditch, it is best to have the downspout dumping into a tile to carry away the water, this tile can empty out on the lawn away from the house. Having the downspouts terminate on top of the ground, close to the house is just asking for problems. Terminating the tile to daylight away from the house is the best way to handle rain water. You can run separate tiles from each downspout or you can have branch tiles that come off a main tile to the downspouts. I have all my roof gutters run into a tile system, I went with 6" main line with 4" feeder branches run from the downspouts to the main. Adding the tile to the roof gutter system dried up a couple of spots around the house where the rain water would set and soak away before I added the tile system.
If you are able to physically able to dig the ditches than you can save some money by doing it yourself. I helped a friend install tiles to his downspouts on a lot that you could not get a mini excavator into the backyard, we used a front tile tiller to loosen the soil and than you could shovel it out easily. We turned the two tines that stick out, in to the center and than the tiller would easily follow the ditch line once it was established.
Have the gutters sized by a reputable company also, If you are going to do this than you really only wnat to do it once. The gutter has to be sized to match the sq.ft. of the roof section it services, if you size them too small than they will overflow in heavy rain. \
Dan.
1.) Do you have enough fall to properly pitch your drain tile to daylight? Proper pitch being between 1/8" - 1/4" per foot of run. Anymore than 1/4" per foot, the water can run away from the solids in it, and any less than 1/8" per foot the water is not following fast enough to carry the solids along. Either of these scenarios can lead to clogging of the tile.
2.) are your cellar walls cut stone, stacked field stone or rubble type construction. Digging in the area of rubble type can be a problem but can be done. Cut stone and stacked field stone are the easiest of the old foundations to work around, as they are more stable than the rubble type is.
Now, onto the main subject. If you wish dry up your cellar than digging out the foundation and installing a footer drain around the perimeter, with a membrane on the outside of the walls is your only real recourse to a wet basement. Adding gutters to the prevent the water from getting the chance to soak into the ground will help a lot, but if the water is coming from another source, the gutters will not cure the problem.
Either way you do this, you will need to dig some ditch, it is best to have the downspout dumping into a tile to carry away the water, this tile can empty out on the lawn away from the house. Having the downspouts terminate on top of the ground, close to the house is just asking for problems. Terminating the tile to daylight away from the house is the best way to handle rain water. You can run separate tiles from each downspout or you can have branch tiles that come off a main tile to the downspouts. I have all my roof gutters run into a tile system, I went with 6" main line with 4" feeder branches run from the downspouts to the main. Adding the tile to the roof gutter system dried up a couple of spots around the house where the rain water would set and soak away before I added the tile system.
If you are able to physically able to dig the ditches than you can save some money by doing it yourself. I helped a friend install tiles to his downspouts on a lot that you could not get a mini excavator into the backyard, we used a front tile tiller to loosen the soil and than you could shovel it out easily. We turned the two tines that stick out, in to the center and than the tiller would easily follow the ditch line once it was established.
Have the gutters sized by a reputable company also, If you are going to do this than you really only wnat to do it once. The gutter has to be sized to match the sq.ft. of the roof section it services, if you size them too small than they will overflow in heavy rain. \
Dan.
- Rick 386
- Member
- Posts: 2508
- Joined: Mon. Jan. 28, 2008 4:26 pm
- Location: Royersford, Pa
- Stoker Coal Boiler: AA 260 heating both sides of twin farmhouse
- Hot Air Coal Stoker Stove: LL Hyfire II w/ coaltrol in garage
- Coal Size/Type: Pea in AA 260, Rice in LL Hyfire II
- Other Heating: Gas fired infared at work
- Contact:
I really don't know which one is best for you up theah......but every time we come to Maine,I don't see a lot of gutters on houses. Most just seem to use the metal roofs and cover the plants with boards to keep the sliding snow from crushing them.
And as was mentioned, how many trees are nearby which would allow leaves to cog the gutters and downspouts ??
Rick
And as was mentioned, how many trees are nearby which would allow leaves to cog the gutters and downspouts ??
Rick
-
- Member
- Posts: 191
- Joined: Tue. Dec. 17, 2013 11:01 am
- Location: Benton,ME
- Hot Air Coal Stoker Stove: Leisure Line Pioneer LE top vent
- Coal Size/Type: Rice
WNY wrote:I had gutters put on with the new roof 8+ years ago and never had a problem with them ripping off. we've had some ice build up at times, but usually not too bad.
If you have good attic insulation, the stuff doesn't melt as much and you don't get the ice build up.
You can also roof rake , long pole with a a puller on the end to pull the snow off the ends of your eves if you get a lot of snow, thats what I do (and need to today or tomorrow, we just got 10+ inches and it helps keep the ice from forming at the ends.
Check this roof rake or shovel out
-
- Member
- Posts: 6446
- Joined: Mon. Apr. 16, 2007 9:34 pm
- Location: Central Maine
- Hand Fed Coal Stove: DS Machine 1300 with hopper
- Coal Size/Type: Blaschak Anthracite Nut
- Other Heating: Oil hot water radiators (fuel oil); propane
Very clever, but I wonder if it would work for someone who only speaks English.scoobydoo wrote:Check this roof rake or shovel out
-
- Member
- Posts: 6446
- Joined: Mon. Apr. 16, 2007 9:34 pm
- Location: Central Maine
- Hand Fed Coal Stove: DS Machine 1300 with hopper
- Coal Size/Type: Blaschak Anthracite Nut
- Other Heating: Oil hot water radiators (fuel oil); propane
Yes, plenty of fall to work with, but I didn't realize the proper slope was quite so critical. That's good to know.Lu47Dan wrote:rberq, two questions.
1.) Do you have enough fall to properly pitch your drain tile to daylight?
2.) are your cellar walls cut stone, stacked field stone or rubble type construction.
Cellar walls are stacked field stone. That's a clever idea about using the tiller to loosen the soil. It might be the best way for the back side of my house where the ground slopes away pretty steeply in a some places. But wouldn't it be best to have the sides of the trench pretty well compacted?
-
- Member
- Posts: 6515
- Joined: Sun. Feb. 10, 2008 3:48 pm
- Location: Cape Cod, MA
- Stoker Coal Boiler: want AA130
- Hand Fed Coal Stove: DS Machine BS#4, Harman MKII, Hitzer 503,...
- Coal Size/Type: Pea/Nut/Stove
Large stone on the drip line 3/4"...
2' wide drip line center...
dig down below frost line on the outside...
pitching up to 8"-12" against the foundation...
line the bottom with pond liner running up the foundation wall 6"...
up the outside ditch wall 12" but keeping below the foundation height...
perforated pipe in the trench at the low side...
creating a bowl that if the perforated pipe fails to work will spill AWAY from the house...
drain to daylight...
Move plants out front of this system...
A-frame protect small shrubs...
I too prefer the straight pipe vs the coils...
Town mandated a drainage plan on my property...
I got a Masters in Drainage...
2' wide drip line center...
dig down below frost line on the outside...
pitching up to 8"-12" against the foundation...
line the bottom with pond liner running up the foundation wall 6"...
up the outside ditch wall 12" but keeping below the foundation height...
perforated pipe in the trench at the low side...
creating a bowl that if the perforated pipe fails to work will spill AWAY from the house...
drain to daylight...
Move plants out front of this system...
A-frame protect small shrubs...
I too prefer the straight pipe vs the coils...
Town mandated a drainage plan on my property...
I got a Masters in Drainage...
-
- Member
- Posts: 6446
- Joined: Mon. Apr. 16, 2007 9:34 pm
- Location: Central Maine
- Hand Fed Coal Stove: DS Machine 1300 with hopper
- Coal Size/Type: Blaschak Anthracite Nut
- Other Heating: Oil hot water radiators (fuel oil); propane
Everybody says "drain to daylight", but why? Why not drain into a pit or trench filled with crushed stone, but covered over and seeded like the rest of the lawn? Must be a reason ....CapeCoaler wrote:drain to daylight...
-
- Member
- Posts: 2270
- Joined: Sun. Sep. 30, 2012 8:20 pm
- Location: Ithaca,NY
drain to daylight really means to drain to a spot lower than the bottom of your ditch. IF YOU DRAIN TO A SEEPAGE PIT then it ok so long as its lower than the lowest point your trying to drain. However if your pit becomes full water will back up your drain and you wont know it till its too late. If you always drain to daylight (literally) then you don't have to be concerned about that
waldo
waldo